In a guest column published by the Richmond Times-Dispatch, HOME of VA executive director Thomas Okuda Fitzpatrick wrote about zoning barriers and opportunities in Virginia. With permission from the Times-Dispatch, we share Tom’s essay here:
We zoned out affordable housing. We can zone it back in.
Thomas Okuda Fitzpatrick
When I graduated college, I went looking for an apartment to rent. Fresh off campus, my budget was tight, so it had to be affordable. In Richmond, my options were few.
Sound familiar?
If the housing market worked like other markets, this situation would be rare. Reliable demand from new grads — Virginia’s colleges and universities granted more than 57,000 bachelor’s degrees in 2024 — would spur supply of affordable rental housing. Developers would compete for price and quality. And like most things large numbers of people buy or rent, it would be widely available.
Clearly that isn’t the case. There are many reasons for this, but one looms large — zoning.
The rules cities and counties make about what we may build, and where, can open up housing opportunities. But all too often, they shut them out.
HousingForward Virginia, where I serve on the Board of Directors, recently released a tool that helps visualize this problem across the Commonwealth. It’s called the Virginia Zoning Atlas — an interactive map that shows where zoning allows Virginians to build housing.
Fire it up and you’ll see a toggle switch showing where it’s legal to build single-family homes. Suddenly the state is bathed in a colorful overlay, as this type of housing — generally the most expensive — can be built in most places. In Richmond, you’ll see the same broad coverage for areas where a homeowner can construct a granny flat, or accessory dwelling unit (ADU), as the City made ADUs legal to build by-right in 2023.
But flip the switch to apartment buildings, like the ones I was seeking out after college, and the color drains away. Zoom out to our region as a whole, and you’ll see only a scattershot of opportunities — and permission to build doesn’t guarantee affordability.
The Virginia Zoning Atlas makes the limits on housing choice especially clear when you select the switch for “missing middle housing.” These areas, where typically more affordable homes like duplexes and triplexes can be built without costly permitting and delays, are about as scarce as apartment zones.
The Atlas also links to this snapshot showing that duplexes are allowed on just 6% of land across the entire Richmond region. Triplexes are among the rarest breeds, allowed on just 1% of land here. And apartments are prohibited on 85% of the region’s acres.
Housing costs have grown eye-watering for many reasons — even before the unforced errors of tariff hikes on building materials and terrorizing immigrant communities, including many who work in the construction trades, with threats of deportation. Interest rates play a major role, too.
But our tight housing market fundamentally results from too little construction. When you compare Virginia’s population over time with annual housing permits granted, you find that the Commonwealth’s permitting in 2025 was less than half the 1970 rate — 3.73 housing permits per 1,000 residents in 2025 vs. 9.36 in 1970.
A big reason? Zoning.
After cities and counties across the Commonwealth Today in Richmond and many parts of the state, building housing that falls outside existing zoning rules can require a lengthy process of permitting and review — a process that adds to the price.
In Richmond, the Homes for All Our Neighbors coalition has called on planners and Council members to remove restrictive zoning rules across the city. The latest draft of Richmond’s Code Refresh makes meaningful moves in this direction, but still falls far short of what’s needed — even according to the City’s own award-winning master plan.
In Chesterfield, the Planning Department recently announced a draft land use plan that sharply cuts the number of homes that can be built across vast swaths of the county. Henrico has made a historic investment in affordable housing, but that trust fund focuses on homeownership rather than rental housing.
My colleagues at Housing Opportunities Made Equal of Virginia, where I’m the executive director, have built partnerships with advocates and lawmakers who see not only the urgent need for change, but also the potential. Recent steps in the right direction include a bill passed this year that will make it easier for qualifying congregations and nonprofits to build affordable housing on land they own beginning January 1, 2027. But even as other states — as varied as Texas, California, New Hampshire, and Oregon — pass sweeping bills to unlock housing construction, Virginia remains stuck in local-level zoning binds.
The Virginia Zoning Atlas helps us to see this. The lack of affordable options faced by new grads, young families, and low-income workers? Many of those missing homes were zoned out of existence. That was a policy choice.
It’s time we made better ones.
Originally published in Richmond Times-Dispatch, October 10, 2026




