How We Choose Cases
We can’t take every case. With this approach, we look for cases with the potential for broad, enduring impact. We ask these questions when prioritizing litigation opportunities:
01
Could it set a precedent protecting Virginians well beyond the people most directly involved?
02
Could it show a pattern or practice of discrimination, rather than a single incident?
03
Could it target practices common across the housing industry, or affecting multiple communities?
04
Does it reflect what our housing counselors hear from clients every day?
Results
The following cases comprise a selection of the many litigation efforts we’ve launched over more than a half-century, earning justice in housing across Virginia.
Havens Realty Corp. v. Coleman (1982)
HOME’s testers documented an apartment complex in Henrico County where Black applicants were told no units were available while telling white applicants the opposite. The US Supreme Court ruled that testers and fair housing organizations have the right to sue. More than four decades later, fair housing groups nationwide still rely on that precedent, one of the most commonly cited cases in social justice litigation.
HOME v. Nationwide Insurance (2000)
Testers posing as homeowners found Nationwide quoting insurance to white applicants while turning away Black applicants in comparable neighborhoods — redlining by another name. A Richmond jury returned a verdict with damages of $100.5 million, the largest civil rights award in US history at the time. The case ultimately settled for $17.5 million, funding home repair, down payment assistance, and foreclosure counseling in Richmond, and Nationwide agreed to change its underwriting practices.
Pitts v. Matthews (2005)
Nealie Pitts saw a for sale sign on a Chesterfield County house and inquired. The owner told her he couldn’t sell to her because she was Black — the neighbors, he said, had decided to keep the area white. HOME sent testers who confirmed her account with the seller cited a deed restriction. Restrictive covenants like the one on this property were once widespread; and though they have been unenforceable since 1948, their continued presence on deeds can create openings for discrimination. The court ruled for Ms. Pitts, and the message carried well past Chesterfield.
HOME v. Shockoe Valley View (2015)
The federal Fair Housing Act requires multifamily housing built after 1991 to be accessible to people with disabilities. But many developers have ignored this. HOME’s 2014 investigation into design and construction violations led to a $600,000 settlement with Shockoe Valley View Apartments — and extensive retrofitting, including accessible routes for wheelchair users and usable features in every unit. Architects and builders across the country took note.
HOME v. Kay Management (2020)
Mara Kniaz and Kuir Phillips lost their home over a decade-old conviction, despite years of living there without incident. Their landlord rejected every applicant with any criminal record — a policy that fell hardest on Black and Latinx renters, given decades of over-policing. A settlement with HOME ended it. Kay Management rewrote its screening policy, and other landlords followed.
How We Build a Case
Most cases begin with what we learn from Virginians who request help when facing housing discrimination. Our fair housing advocates investigate each report of a violation and document what we learn. Over time, as we build systemic cases, evidence from individual reports can help to reveal patterns of discrimination. We also work alongside partner organizations and with pro bono attorneys to bring resources and expertise that complements HOME of VA’s own efforts.
Think You’ve Experienced Housing Discrimination?
Tell us what happened.
Attorneys
We partner with pro bono counsel on fair housing issues across Virginia.

